Lori Vallow Daybell is convicted in her second murder conspiracy case in Arizona

Justice moves swiftly in Arizona. In less than two months, a jury found Lori Vallow guilty of conspiring to kill her niece’s ex-husband—her second conviction in the state. This comes after she was already handed multiple life sentences in Idaho for the deaths of her children and her fifth husband’s late wife.

The latest verdict took jurors under an hour to decide. The speed shocked many, especially given the gravity of the charges. For victims’ families, it was a moment of long-awaited closure.

Sentencing is set for July 25, where Arizona will add to her existing punishments. Though she didn’t represent herself this time, her courtroom demeanor—calm, almost detached—left a chilling impression.

For those following the case, the question isn’t just about punishment but how someone could spiral so far. The legal repercussions are clear. The human cost, however, lingers.

Jury Finds Lori Vallow Daybell Guilty of Conspiring to Kill Brandon Boudreaux

After just 58 minutes of deliberation, the jury found the defendant guilty of plotting to murder Brandon Boudreaux. The speed stunned observers, underscoring the strength of the evidence.

Rapid Deliberations and Verdict

The jury took less than an hour to reach a unanimous decision. Forensic details, including Jeep modifications and digital trails, left little room for doubt. This marked the third guilty verdict in the defendant’s series of trials.

Key Evidence Presented at Trial

Prosecutors highlighted how Alex Cox altered a Jeep—removing seats and wheels—to ambush Boudreaux. Security footage showed the parts stored in a unit linked to the defendant.

Cox’s phone, left in Idaho as an alibi, contradicted his actual location. Ballistics matched his rifle to the 2019 shooting incident. Survivor testimony further cemented the connection.

Prosecutor Treena Kay’s Closing Arguments

Prosecutor Treena Kay dismantled the defense with a simple premise: “The only logical conclusion was conspiracy.” She tied Cox’s actions to the defendant’s directives, emphasizing their shared intent.

Kay’s focus on digital footprints—cell pings, storage unit logs—painted an irrefutable timeline. The jury agreed, sealing the verdict in record time.

The Lori Vallow Daybell Case: A Timeline of Crimes

A chilling pattern emerged as investigators uncovered multiple crimes. From custody disputes to insurance payouts, each event revealed a deeper conspiracy. Here’s how the tragedies unfolded.

Murders of Tylee Ryan and JJ Vallow

The disappearance of two children in 2019 sparked nationwide attention. Tylee Ryan, 16, and JJ, 7, were last seen months before their remains were found in Idaho. Forensic evidence showed signs of concealment and tampering.

A custody battle over JJ and financial stakes—including Social Security benefits—were key motives. Digital records placed the defendant near the burial site around the time of death.

Conspiracy in the Death of Tammy Daybell

Tammy Daybell’s 2019 death was initially ruled natural—until an autopsy revealed asphyxiation. A $1 million life insurance policy, recently altered, pointed to foul play. Phone records tied the defendant to the scene days before the death.

Prosecutors argued this was part of a broader scheme to eliminate obstacles. The jury agreed, labeling it conspiring to kill for financial gain.

Previous Conviction for Charles Vallow’s Murder

In 2019, Charles Vallow was shot dead by the defendant’s brother, Alex Cox. Though Cox claimed self-defense, evidence showed premeditation. Text messages revealed discussions about «removing» Charles weeks earlier.

This marked the first in a series of spousal eliminations. Each case shared eerie similarities: rushed insurance changes, digital trails, and third-party involvement.

Doomsday Beliefs and the Role of Chad Daybell

Extreme beliefs fueled a deadly chain of events in this case. At its core, a radical offshoot of LDS theology spiraled into violence. Chad Daybell, the defendant’s husband, preached that foes were «zombies»—justifying their elimination.

Cult-Like Religious Practices

The group’s doctrine warped morality. Followers labeled critics as «dark spirits,» a tactic used to isolate and manipulate. July 2020’s predicted apocalypse intensified urgency—loyalty meant survival.

Members pooled resources, trusting Daybell’s visions. His self-published books, like those from Spring Creek Book Company, amplified fear. Sales surged as followers prepared for the end.

Chad Daybell’s Influence and Conviction

Daybell’s charisma masked control. He faces the death penalty in Idaho for his role in the murders. Texts revealed his coordination with the defendant, tying theology to crime.

His $2,000 annual income from apocalyptic literature paled next to life insurance payouts. Profit and prophecy merged dangerously.

Financial and Legal Motivations

Deaths unlocked financial gains. Policies on victims’ lives were altered weeks before their murders. This insurance fraud funded the couple’s survivalist plans.

With multiple life sentences already imposed, the legal fallout is vast. Yet the human cost—families shattered by twisted beliefs—remains immeasurable.

Conclusion: Justice Served Amid Ongoing Sentencing

Closure arrives as the legal process nears its final phase. On July 25, Arizona will deliver its sentence, adding to the existing life terms. For victims’ family members, this moment is both an end and a reckoning.

Brandon Boudreaux’s words—calling hate «poison to our souls»—resonate deeply. His forgiveness contrasts the crimes, yet underscores the cost. Justice, though delayed, leaves no room for doubt.

Idaho’s prison system awaits the transfer, closing a chapter marked by tragedy. The legal system’s swift actions remind us: accountability spares no one.